Android – Keep on Waiting?
I believe I want an Android phone.
I am still using my Tmo Dash, which – has been the best phone I ever had. It is nearing 3 years old now (can’t be). It is obsolete and very tired now. But it still works. I just feel somewhat obligated to have a cutting edge phone.
I’ve seen friends upgrade their phones to theiPhoneand new Blackberry models. People love their phones. They are making fun of me.
I more or less decided last Fall that I wanted an Android phone, but not the first version. I expected there to be many more by this time. The 2nd phone has finally arrived – the MyTouch. Not too exciting. I want a keyboard and it just isn’t that slick of a device.
Now we have moved our office from Exchange to Google Apps – and I am using Google Voice for some calls. The Android phone still makes the most sense (but the Dash has adapted well too, to resync the Dash from Exchange to Google actually required a PC).
Anyway, I am tempted to get the MyTouch, but unsure since I’ve waited this long. Here are my reasons not to, but would love your thoughts:
- No keyboard
- Reviews indicate soft keyboard is not very good.
- Press reports suggest new models still coming, but no one knows when.
- New models (Motorola/Bigfoot, HTC Hero, Samsung i7500) already in the blogosphere.
- NYT reports to expect several models this year.
But Android phones are sure coming out slowly. It isn’t clear if/when the new phones will hit this year and which ones will have a keyboard. Tmo is just now launching the MyTouch (2nd generation phone), 9 months after the first. The Hero, is now available in Europe, but I imagine Tmo wants to stall it here so they can sell some MyTouch’s first (they are the same hardware generation).
Back in March, I blogged that Android was the disappointment of the year. Because they are taking so long to get phones on the market.
Honestly, I guess there is no reason I can’t keep waiting- but I ridicule people that wait to by a computer because they think the prices might be dropping soon. That excuse never goes away, and there will always be a better model coming.
I could have bought a G1 last October and almost be done with my 1 year contract. That was the right move in hindisight. But doing so now seems to make no sense.
There are not very many of us telecom types that are still holding out with old phones. Even (formerly) Nokia’s Phoneboy traded his Nokia in for aniPhone and seems to like it. TheiPhone is a respectable device, but I don’t want AT&T; or the Apple Appstore. I am free – no contract and an osolete phone, don’t want to squander that on the wrong device.
What to do, what to do?
Dave,
My friend, we are in the very same boat. I like T-Mobile service and I've gotten by with my Blackberry Pearl for two year, but I need something more.
I've been following some N97 users thinking that the device was interesting, but they are going sour on it. An associate in the UK has the Touch Pro 2(?) and it looks nice, but she's not a demanding user.
There's rumor that we might have 12 Android phones by the end of the year. That's a lotta phones in the pipe. Maybe the poor pipe is stopped up with all that potential!
Ok, here's some speculation and some fact that may or may not help you.
Despite the clunkiness of the G1, it's still the best phone I've ever owned. Sure, it has stuff I don't like, but the things I DO like far outweigh them.
The two main things that made me get the G1 (on the first day it launched) were:
1)Android seemed kind of exciting
and
2)I couldn't live with a soft keyboard any longer.
I won an iPhone in a contest, which moved me off a string of Sidekicks — on which I typed a LOT. I got good on iPhone, but it still drove me nuts, and I was never as fast or accurate as on the Sidekick.
The G1 keyboard is pert-near identical to Sidekick in layout, and is really, really nice to type on.
After 9 months with Android, I can honestly say that it's lived up to the speculative excitement I found in it, and am now developing apps and doing all sorts of crazy things.
As far as phone platforms go, there is simply not another one that will let you do the kinds of things that Android can. Want to replace the dialer with Google Voice? No problem. Want a different SMS client? No problem. Pretty much anything can be overridden by apps, meaning that if you can dream it, it can happen. And that's even BEFORE circumventing the security on the G1…
So anyway, it sounds like you really want Android, but also that you want a phone now. I recommend that you either buy a G1, or hold out 'til the G1v2 somewhere around October. The Android soft keyboard is nice as far as soft keyboards go, but you'll miss real keys. The MyTouch isn't even any beefier performancewise than the G1, so you'd be paying a premium to have a harder time typing.
If you look around, you can often find G1s for $99 with rebates. Amazon often has them.
Also: the contract-break fee is prorated. It starts out at $160, and then falls over time. Chances are that by the time you want out of your contract, it won't really cost all that much to do so.
Hero won't be coming to T-Mobile anytime soon, and likely not other US carriers either. Also, it's a klunky shape, has no keyboard and is reportedly very sluggish.
At least a few of the dozen-plus this year should be in Treo-style formfactors if that's more your thing.
Anyway, my advice is not to wait. Get a refurb G1, look on craigslist for a used one. Just don't buy another phone that's going to make you long after Android for the duration of a new contract.
Also contract-free, unlocked phones will hold their value.
I cancel different contracts and still came out ahead when I sold my iPhone. G1 will be less-valuable, but will still be more than the $100ish you pay for it, even a year from now to those that don't want contracts.
One last thing:
T-Mobile has 14-day unconditional return period, even negating contracts.
Try out a G1 for a few days and see what you think…
I will admit I am not fond of Apple's policies about approving/removing apps from the App Store, nor am I fond of the fact I am unable to legitimately unlock my iPhone. However, I am generally happy with the overall user experience. For those instances where I need to use a different SIM, I've got a drawer full of Nokia phones ready to go 🙂